fix sub/unsub when using "dont unsub"

packages/node_modules/@node-red/nodes/core/network/10-mqtt.js

@@ -219,8 +219,10 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
      * Handle the payload / packet recieved in MQTT In and MQTT Sub nodes
      */
     function subscriptionHandler(node, datatype ,topic, payload, packet) {
-        const v5 = node.brokerConn.options && node.brokerConn.options.protocolVersion == 5;
+        const msg = {topic:topic, payload:null, qos:packet.qos, retain:packet.retain};
-        var msg = {topic:topic, payload:null, qos:packet.qos, retain:packet.retain};
+        const v5 = (node && node.brokerConn) 
+            ? node.brokerConn.v5() 
+            : Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(packet, "properties");
         if(v5 && packet.properties) {
             setStrProp(packet.properties, msg, "responseTopic");
             setBufferProp(packet.properties, msg, "correlationData");
@@ -300,7 +302,7 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
             //}
         }
         msg.payload = payload;
-        if ((node.brokerConn.broker === "localhost")||(node.brokerConn.broker === "127.0.0.1")) {
+        if (node.brokerConn && (node.brokerConn.broker === "localhost" || node.brokerConn.broker === "127.0.0.1")) {
             msg._topic = topic;
         }
         node.send(msg);
@@ -412,6 +414,12 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
         }
     }
 
+    /**
+     * Perform the connect action
+     * @param {MQTTInNode|MQTTOutNode} node
+     * @param {Object} msg
+     * @param {Function} done
+     */
     function handleConnectAction(node, msg, done) {
         let actionData = typeof msg.broker === 'object' ? msg.broker : null;
         if (node.brokerConn.canConnect()) {
@@ -442,12 +450,17 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
         }
     }
 
+    /**
+     * Perform the disconnect action
+     * @param {MQTTInNode|MQTTOutNode} node 
+     * @param {Function} done
+     */
     function handleDisconnectAction(node, done) {
         node.brokerConn.disconnect(function () {
             done();
         });
     }
-
+    const unsubscribeCandidates = {}
     //#endregion  "Supporting functions"
 
     //#region  "Broker node"
@@ -591,10 +604,9 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
             if (typeof node.cleansession === 'undefined') {
                 node.cleansession = true;
             }
-            if (typeof node.autoUnsubscribe === 'undefined') {
+            if (typeof node.autoUnsubscribe !== 'boolean') {
                 node.autoUnsubscribe = true;
             }
-
             //use url or build a url from usetls://broker:port
             if (node.url && node.brokerurl !== node.url) {
                 node.brokerurl = node.url;
@@ -664,7 +676,6 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
             node.options.password = node.password;
             node.options.keepalive = node.keepalive;
             node.options.clean = node.cleansession;
-            node.options.autoUnsubscribe = node.autoUnsubscribe;
             node.options.clientId = node.clientid || 'nodered_' + RED.util.generateId();
             node.options.reconnectPeriod = RED.settings.mqttReconnectTime||5000;
             delete node.options.protocolId; //V4+ default
@@ -702,7 +713,8 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
                 node.options.rejectUnauthorized = (node.verifyservercert == "true" || node.verifyservercert === true);
             }
         }
-
+        node.v5 = () => node.options && node.options.protocolVersion == 5
+        node.subscriptionIdentifiersAvailable = () => node.v5() && node.serverProperties && node.serverProperties.subscriptionIdentifiersAvailable
         n.autoConnect = n.autoConnect === "false" || n.autoConnect === false ? false : true;
         node.setOptions(n, true);
 
@@ -784,18 +796,11 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
                         // Re-subscribe to stored topics
                         for (var s in node.subscriptions) {
                             if (node.subscriptions.hasOwnProperty(s)) {
-                                let topic = s;
-                                let qos = 0;
-                                let _options = {};
                                 for (var r in node.subscriptions[s]) {
                                     if (node.subscriptions[s].hasOwnProperty(r)) {
-                                        qos = Math.max(qos,node.subscriptions[s][r].qos);
+                                        node.subscribe(node.subscriptions[s][r])
-                                        _options = node.subscriptions[s][r].options;
-                                        node._clientOn('message',node.subscriptions[s][r].handler);
                                     }
                                 }
-                                _options.qos = _options.qos || qos;
-                                node.client.subscribe(topic, _options);
                             }
                         }
 
@@ -857,16 +862,22 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
             if(!node.client) { return _callback(); }
             if(node.closing) { return _callback(); }
 
+            /**
+             * Call end and wait for the client to end (or timeout)
+             * @param {mqtt.MqttClient} client The broker client
+             * @param {number} ms The time to wait for the client to end
+             * @returns 
+             */
             let waitEnd = (client, ms) => {
                 return new Promise( (resolve, reject) => {
                     node.closing = true;
-                    if(!client) {
+                    if (!client) {
                         resolve();
                     } else {
                         const t = setTimeout(() => {
                             //clean end() has exceeded WAIT_END, lets force end!
                             client && client.end(true);
-                            reject();
+                            resolve();
                         }, ms);
                         client.end(() => {
                             clearTimeout(t);
@@ -893,64 +904,222 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
         }
         node.subscriptionIds = {};
         node.subid = 1;
-        node.subscribe = function (topic,options,callback,ref) {
+
-            ref = ref||0;
+        //typedef for subscription object:
-            var qos;
+        /** 
-            if(typeof options == "object") {
+         * @typedef {Object} Subscription
-                qos = options.qos;
+         * @property {String} topic - topic to subscribe to
-            } else {
+         * @property {Object} [options] - options object
-                qos = options;
+         * @property {Number} [options.qos] - quality of service
-                options = {};
+         * @property {Number} [options.nl] - no local
+         * @property {Number} [options.rap] - retain as published
+         * @property {Number} [options.rh] - retain handling
+         * @property {Number} [options.properties] - MQTT 5.0 properties
+         * @property {Number} [options.properties.subscriptionIdentifier] - MQTT 5.0 subscription identifier
+         * @property {Number} [options.properties.userProperties] - MQTT 5.0 user properties
+         * @property {Function} callback
+         * @property {String} ref - reference to the node that created the subscription
+         */
+
+        /**
+         * Create a subscription object
+         * @param {String} _topic - topic to subscribe to
+         * @param {Object} _options - options object
+         * @param {String} _ref - reference to the node that created the subscription
+         * @returns {Subscription}
+         */
+        function createSubscriptionObject(_topic, _options, _ref, _brokerId) {
+            /** @type {Subscription} */
+            const subscription = {};
+            const ref = _ref || 0;
+            let options
+            let qos = 1 // default to QoS 1 (AWS and several other brokers don't support QoS 2)
+            
+            // if options is an object, then clone it
+            if (typeof _options == "object") {
+                options = RED.util.cloneMessage(_options || {})
+                qos = _options.qos;
+            } else if (typeof _options == "number") {
+                qos = _options;
             }
+            options = options || {};
+
+            // sanitise qos
+            if (typeof qos === "number" && qos >= 0 && qos <= 2) {
                 options.qos = qos;
+            }
+            
+            subscription.topic = _topic;
+            subscription.qos = qos;
+            subscription.options = RED.util.cloneMessage(options);
+            subscription.ref = ref;
+            subscription.brokerId = _brokerId;
+            return subscription;
+        }
+
+        /**
+         * If topic is a subscription object, then use that, otherwise look up the topic in 
+         * the  subscriptions object.  If the topic is not found, then create a new subscription
+         * object and add it to the subscriptions object.
+         * @param {Subscription|String} topic 
+         * @param {*} options 
+         * @param {*} callback 
+         * @param {*} ref 
+         */
+        node.subscribe = function (topic, options, callback, ref) {
+            /** @type {Subscription} */ 
+            let subscription
+            let doCompare = false
+            let changesFound = false
+
+            // function signature 1: subscribe(subscription: Subscription)
+            if (typeof topic === "object" && topic !== null) {
+                subscription = topic
+                topic = subscription.topic
+                options = subscription.options
+                ref = subscription.ref
+                callback = subscription.callback
+            }
+
+            // function signature 2: subscribe(topic: String, options: Object, callback: Function, ref: String)
+            else if (typeof topic === "string") {
+                // since this is a call where all params are provided, it might be
+                // a node change (modification) so we need to check for changes
+                doCompare = true
+                subscription = node.subscriptions[topic] && node.subscriptions[topic][ref]
+            }
+
+            // bad function call
+            else {
+                console.warn('Invalid call to node.subscribe')
+                return
+            }
+            const thisBrokerId = node.type === 'mqtt-broker' ? node.id : node.broker
+
+            // unsubscribe topics where the broker has changed
+            const oldBrokerSubs = (unsubscribeCandidates[ref] || []).filter(sub => sub.brokerId !== thisBrokerId)
+            oldBrokerSubs.forEach(sub => {
+                /** @type {MQTTBrokerNode} */
+                const _brokerConn = RED.nodes.getNode(sub.brokerId)
+                if (_brokerConn) {
+                    _brokerConn.unsubscribe(sub.topic, sub.ref, true)
+                }
+            })
+            
+            // if subscription is found (or sent in as a parameter), then check for changes.
+            // if there are any changes requested, tidy up the old subscription
+            if (subscription) {
+                if (doCompare) {
+                    // compare the current sub to the passed in parameters. Use RED.util.compareObjects against
+                    // only the minimal set of properties to identify if the subscription has changed
+                    const currentSubscription = createSubscriptionObject(subscription.topic, subscription.options, subscription.ref)
+                    const newSubscription = createSubscriptionObject(topic, options, ref)
+                    changesFound = RED.util.compareObjects(currentSubscription, newSubscription) === false
+                }
+            }
+
+            if (changesFound) {
+                if (subscription.handler) {
+                    node._clientRemoveListeners('message', subscription.handler)
+                    subscription.handler = null
+                }
+                const _brokerConn = RED.nodes.getNode(subscription.brokerId)
+                if (_brokerConn) {
+                    _brokerConn.unsubscribe(subscription.topic, subscription.ref, true)
+                }
+            }
+
+            // clean up the unsubscribe candidate list
+            delete unsubscribeCandidates[ref]
+
+            // determine if this is an existing subscription
+            const existingSubscription = typeof subscription === "object" && subscription !== null
+
+            // if existing subscription is not found or has changed, create a new subscription object
+            if (existingSubscription === false || changesFound) {
+                subscription = createSubscriptionObject(topic, options, ref, node.id)
+            }
+
+            // setup remainder of subscription properties and event handling
+            node.subscriptions[topic] = node.subscriptions[topic] || {};
+            node.subscriptions[topic][ref] = subscription
             if (!node.subscriptionIds[topic]) {
                 node.subscriptionIds[topic] = node.subid++;
             }
-            options.properties = options.properties || {};
+            subscription.options = subscription.options || {};
-            options.properties.subscriptionIdentifier = node.subscriptionIds[topic];
+            subscription.options.properties = options.properties || {};
+            subscription.options.properties.subscriptionIdentifier = node.subscriptionIds[topic];
+            subscription.callback = callback;
 
-            node.subscriptions[topic] = node.subscriptions[topic]||{};
+            // if the client is connected, then setup the handler and subscribe
-            var sub = {
-                topic:topic,
-                qos:qos,
-                options:options,
-                handler:function(mtopic,mpayload, mpacket) {
-                    if(mpacket.properties && options.properties && mpacket.properties.subscriptionIdentifier && options.properties.subscriptionIdentifier && (mpacket.properties.subscriptionIdentifier !== options.properties.subscriptionIdentifier) ) {
-                        //do nothing as subscriptionIdentifier does not match
-                    } else if (matchTopic(topic,mtopic)) {
-                        callback(mtopic,mpayload, mpacket);
-                    }
-                },
-                ref: ref
-            };
-            node.subscriptions[topic][ref] = sub;
             if (node.connected) {
-                node._clientOn('message',sub.handler);
+                const subIdsAvailable = node.subscriptionIdentifiersAvailable()
-                node.client.subscribe(topic, options);
-            }
-        };
 
-        node.unsubscribe = function (topic, ref, removed) {
+                if (!subscription.handler) {
+                    subscription.handler = function (mtopic, mpayload, mpacket) {
+                        const sops = subscription.options ? subscription.options.properties : {}
+                        const pops = mpacket.properties || {}
+                        if (subIdsAvailable && pops.subscriptionIdentifier && sops.subscriptionIdentifier && (pops.subscriptionIdentifier !== sops.subscriptionIdentifier)) {
+                            //do nothing as subscriptionIdentifier does not match
+                        } else if (matchTopic(topic, mtopic)) {
+                            subscription.callback && subscription.callback(mtopic, mpayload, mpacket)
+                        }
+                    }
+                }
+                node._clientOn('message', subscription.handler)
+                // if the broker doesn't support subscription identifiers, then don't send them (AWS support)
+                if (subscription.options.properties && subscription.options.properties.subscriptionIdentifier && subIdsAvailable !== true) {
+                    delete subscription.options.properties.subscriptionIdentifier
+                }
+                node.client.subscribe(topic, subscription.options)
+            }
+
+        }
+
+        node.unsubscribe = function (topic, ref, removeClientSubscription) {
             ref = ref||0;
-            var sub = node.subscriptions[topic];
+            const unsub = removeClientSubscription || node.autoUnsubscribe !== false
+            const sub = node.subscriptions[topic];
+            let brokerId = node.id
             if (sub) {
                 if (sub[ref]) {
-                    if(node.client) {
+                    brokerId = sub[ref].brokerId || brokerId
-                        node._clientRemoveListeners('message',sub[ref].handler);
+                    if(node.client && sub[ref].handler) {
+                        node._clientRemoveListeners('message', sub[ref].handler);
+                        sub[ref].handler = null
                     }
-                    delete sub[ref];
+                    if (unsub) {
+                        delete sub[ref]
                     }
-                //TODO: Review. The `if(removed)` was commented out to always delete and remove subscriptions.
+                }
-                // if we dont then property changes dont get applied and old subs still trigger
+                // if instructed to remove the actual MQTT client subscription 
-                //if (removed) {
+                if (unsub) {
+                    // if there are no more subscriptions for the topic, then remove the topic
                     if (Object.keys(sub).length === 0) {
+                        try {
+                            node.client.unsubscribe(topic)
+                        } catch (_err) {
+                            // do nothing
+                        } finally {
+                            // remove unsubscribe candidate as it is now REALLY unsubscribed
                             delete node.subscriptions[topic];
                             delete node.subscriptionIds[topic];
-                        if (node.connected) {
+                            if (unsubscribeCandidates[ref]) {
-                            node.client.unsubscribe(topic);
+                                unsubscribeCandidates[ref] = unsubscribeCandidates[ref].filter(sub => sub.topic !== topic)
                             }
                         }
-                //}
+                    }
+                } else {
+                    // if instructed to not remove the client subscription, then add it to the candidate list
+                    // of subscriptions to be removed when the the same ref is used in a subsequent subscribe
+                    // and the topic has changed
+                    unsubscribeCandidates[ref] = unsubscribeCandidates[ref] || [];
+                    unsubscribeCandidates[ref].push({
+                        topic: topic,
+                        ref: ref,
+                        brokerId: brokerId
+                    })
+                }
             }
         };
         node.topicAliases = {};
@@ -988,7 +1157,7 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
                     setStrProp(msg, options.properties, "contentType");
                     setIntProp(msg, options.properties, "messageExpiryInterval", 0);
                     setUserProperties(msg.userProperties, options.properties);
-                    setIntProp(msg, options.properties, "topicAlias", 1, node.serverProperties.topicAliasMaximum || 0);
+                    setIntProp(msg, options.properties, "topicAlias", 1, bsp.topicAliasMaximum || 0);
                     setBoolProp(msg, options.properties, "payloadFormatIndicator");
                     //FUTURE setIntProp(msg, options.properties, "subscriptionIdentifier", 1, 268435455);
 
@@ -1124,7 +1293,7 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
                         if(node.rap === "true" || node.rap === true) options.rap = true;
                         else if(node.rap === "false" || node.rap === false) options.rap = false;
                     }
-
+                    node._topic = node.topic; // store the original topic incase node is later changed
                     node.brokerConn.subscribe(node.topic,options,function(topic, payload, packet) {
                         subscriptionHandler(node, node.datatype, topic, payload, packet);
                     },node.id);
@@ -1177,7 +1346,7 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
                     }
                     if (action === Actions.UNSUBSCRIBE) {
                         subscriptions.forEach(function (sub) {
-                            node.brokerConn.unsubscribe(sub.topic, node.id);
+                            node.brokerConn.unsubscribe(sub.topic, node.id, true);
                             delete node.dynamicSubs[sub.topic];
                         })
                         //user can access current subscriptions through the complete node is so desired
@@ -1187,7 +1356,7 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
                         subscriptions.forEach(function (sub) {
                             //always unsubscribe before subscribe to prevent multiple subs to same topic
                             if (node.dynamicSubs[sub.topic]) {
-                                node.brokerConn.unsubscribe(sub.topic, node.id);
+                                node.brokerConn.unsubscribe(sub.topic, node.id, true);
                                 delete node.dynamicSubs[sub.topic];
                             }
 
@@ -1233,17 +1402,13 @@ module.exports = function(RED) {
             node.on('close', function(removed, done) {
                 if (node.brokerConn) {
                     if(node.isDynamic) {
-                        if (node.brokerConn.options.autoUnsubscribe) {
                         Object.keys(node.dynamicSubs).forEach(function (topic) {
                             node.brokerConn.unsubscribe(topic, node.id, removed);
                         });
                         node.dynamicSubs = {};
-                        }
                     } else {
-                        if (node.brokerConn.options.autoUnsubscribe) {
                         node.brokerConn.unsubscribe(node.topic, node.id, removed);
                     }
-                    }
                     node.brokerConn.deregister(node, done, removed);
                     node.brokerConn = null;
                 } else {